GENIUS Act Guarantees Don't Cover DeFi Lending, Why?

Angel Doris Angel Doris 11 Nov 2026 23:59 WIB
Jaminan Undang-Undang GENIUS Tak Sentuh Pinjaman DeFi, Mengapa?
Illustration: GENIUS Act Guarantees Don't Cover DeFi Lending, Why?
Slot Iklan Top

JAKARTA – A sharp spotlight is cast on a significant loophole in the digital asset investment protection framework after the GENIUS Act, designed to provide security guarantees, apparently does not cover decentralized finance (DeFi) lending. This situation has triggered concerns among institutions considering the DeFi market, highlighting fundamental risks related to the ability to change loan terms and vulnerability to price manipulation.

The GENIUS Act, which aims to boost confidence and security in the crypto sector, now faces criticism due to its limited scope. Industry observers and market participants question the effectiveness of such regulation in the dynamic and often anonymous DeFi ecosystem, where the intermediary-free structure is both an attraction and a potential pitfall.

Many large institutions, before deciding to invest in DeFi lending, naturally ask a fundamental question: which markets are safest? This is a crucial question given the volatility and complexity of digital assets.

However, according to Mike Hathaway and Joseph Quintilian of Ajna, that question is misplaced. They argue that the focus should shift from merely seeking the 'safest market' to identifying 'who can change a loan's terms after the money is lent?' This perspective highlights the core of governance risk within DeFi protocols.

The flexibility of smart contracts and token-based governance, which characterize DeFi, often allows token holders to vote on changes to protocol parameters. While designed for decentralization, this mechanism can be a double-edged sword, potentially affecting loan terms and conditions without the direct consent of all parties.

This issue becomes highly relevant in the context of DeFi lending vulnerabilities. Even with stablecoins claimed to be fully asset-backed, protection against these risks is not automatically guaranteed. Hathaway and Quintilian emphasize that stablecoins pegged to real-world assets do not necessarily protect borrowers from unexpected changes.

They underline two main threats faced by DeFi lending, regardless of stablecoin assurances:

  • Token Vote: Collective decisions by token holders through a voting mechanism can drastically alter key parameters of a protocol, including interest rates, collateral requirements, or even liquidation rules, after a loan has been disbursed. This creates significant uncertainty for lenders.
  • Faulty Price Feed: DeFi protocols' reliance on oracles to fetch off-chain price data is another vulnerability. If a price feed is compromised, hacked, or intentionally manipulated, collateral values can be misjudged, leading to unfair liquidations or significant losses for parties involved.

These risks redefine the concept of security in a decentralized financial environment. Institutional investors must perform far more comprehensive due diligence, not only on project fundamentals but also on the governance structure and reliability of the oracle systems used.

This development reinforces the narrative for greater transparency and independent audits within the DeFi ecosystem. As traditional financial institutions like Deutsche Bank begin to offer digital asset custody services, security and regulatory standards are expected to become increasingly stringent.

Therefore, while the GENIUS Act seeks to provide a regulatory framework, the unique architecture of DeFi demands a more nuanced approach. Policymakers and protocol developers must collaborate to bridge the gap between innovation and consumer protection, ensuring that the growth of this sector can be sustainable.

Editorial Insight: The GENIUS Act's limitations in covering DeFi lending reveal fundamental challenges in regulating rapidly evolving financial technology. This is not merely about legal scope but also about a deep understanding of the intrinsic risk mechanisms in decentralized systems. Without a clear framework for governance accountability and oracle data integrity, institutional investor confidence will remain fragile. The future of DeFi may hinge on the industry's ability to proactively address these gaps, perhaps through robust industry standards or more manipulation-resistant technological innovations, before regulators impose stricter limitations.

Valid Information Official Reference Source
www.coindesk.com
Angel Doris

About the Author

Angel Doris

Journalist and Editor at Cognito Daily. Presenting the latest and factual information for readers.

Slot Iklan Bottom

Share Article:

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!

Ad